Phiaton PS300 NC Noise
Cancelling Headphones
|
|
There's a very subtle gold tint to the otherwise
standard silver color of the Phiaton PS300 headphones.
They also bear a remarkable similarity to the Bose QC3
headphones in terms of design and appearance. Is this
just a coincidence?
Part of a series on noise
reducing headphones - click the links on the right for extra
reviews and commentary |
Just like the earlier Plane
Quiet NC model headphones that had similar appearing competitors
that did not perform as well, so too now does the Bose QC3 have
these Phiaton PS300 similarly appearing headphones as a
competitor.
But while external appearances
are very similar, it is clear that the internal electronics are
very different, making for quite different performance both in
terms of noise cancelling and sound quality.
These headphones come with a
good range of accessories included, and can be found 'on the
street' for much less than their list price ($200 instead of
$300) making them better value than the high end QC3. This
cost saving is however matched by noise cancelling and sound
reproduction performance that is not as good as offered by the
QC3.
Executive Summary
The Phiaton PS300NC
headphones look very similar to the Bose QC3 headphones, but in
terms of performance, the QC3's are appreciably better.
Don't be deceived by their external similarity.
On the other hand, with a
street price of $200, the
Phiaton headphones are much better value, and come with more
inclusions.
The Phiaton PS300 NC Noise
Cancelling Headphones - What You Get
The Phiaton PS300 NC noise
cancelling headphones come attractively packed in a cardboard
box with plastic cut-away window to show the headphones inside.
Inside the easily opened box are the
headphones themselves, of course. In addition, there is
not one but two of the tiny Lithium-polymer rechargeable
batteries that power the headphones, and a clever USB powered
charger for the batteries.
The charger ends in a short
USB cable and plug, so you can charge from any USB power source.
And, just in case you don't have a USB power source handy, Phiaton also provide
a 'brick' wall charger, complete with a very generous set of
five different plug adapters (US, UK, Australia/NZ, and both the
thick and thin European styles) that should allow the
multi-voltage charger to work in just about anywhere in the
world.
Full marks to Phiaton on
their comprehensive approach to providing you with lots of
options to recharge the batteries (and bonus marks for providing
two rather than only one battery).
In addition, there's the
essential audio cable with a standard 1/8" (3.5mm) jack at one
end to plug into any audio source, and a smaller (perhaps
2.5mm?) jack at the other end to plug into the headphones.
Two plug adapters are also included - one to convert to the 1/4"
headphone jack seen on, eg, home stereos, and the other to
convert to the double pronged plugs sometimes seen on airplane seats.
The cable is a generous 60"
in length, and has a 'mute' switch in it about 18" from the
headphone end. Pressing the mute switch reduces the sound
volume, but doesn't eliminate it entirely, and the noise
cancellation remains on or off, unaffected by the position of
the mute switch. This can be convenient on a flight when
the flight attendant stops to offer you a drink or meal (on
those rare occasions these days when food is still served).
It is disappointing that
there isn't a regular 3.5mm diameter socket at the headphone end
as well - this
would make it easy to replace the audio cord if it ever breaks
or is lost. It is hard to think that the minimal
difference in size/space required for a 3.5mm vs 2.5mm plug was
impossible to accommodate.
The headphones have hinges
where the earcups meet the headband, allowing them to be folded
into a space efficient compact size for carrying. This
translates into a nice little protective
carry case, which is considerably smaller than the Bose QC3
carry case (the QC3 aren't hinged at all).
The carry case is definitely
compact, but is too small for the
headphones and the wall charger to fit in. You can
fit the headphones, spare battery, and USB charger into the
carry case with a bit of careful arranging, but there's no way
to also include the mains charger. Of course this is not a
deal breaker at all, and is probably a fair design compromise.
Lastly, there is a massive 106 page
manual and a warranty card. But - no need for alarm.
The headphones are easy to operate.
The reason the manual is so big is because it is printed in
multiple languages - only 16 pages are in 'English'.
Unfortunately, the 'English' is a
poor quality translation of a document that was
originally written in perhaps Chinese or Korean.
Some of the content is
extremely hard to understand, such as the full page explanation,
complete with diagram, about their 'VHST'. Sorry, I've no
idea what VHST stands for, although Phiaton have trademarked it,
and I've also no idea what it does or why, even after trying to
understand the explanation.
The warranty is for one year
and appears to be transferable to subsequent owners. But
it does have a strange quirk - if you have a warranty claim,
Phiaton reserves the right to decide if it will repair or
replace the headphones (this is standard) or alternatively to
simply refund you your money, less depreciation (at an unstated
rate). So what happens if you have a problem after owning
the headphones for six months - does that mean perhaps that
Phiaton will simply refund you have the price you originally
paid, rather than repair/replace?
This sort of warranty sounds
more like the 'warranties' you get with a car battery or tires,
whereby you invariably end up paying close to full list price
any time you have to make a claim.
Noise Cancelling
The Phiaton PS300 headphones
provide good but not great noise cancelling. You'll
absolutely notice a good reduction in background noise when you
turn them on, and this will definitely help your comfort and
allow you to emerge the other end of a long plane journey
feeling more refreshed. But they're not in the top level
of noise cancelling.
They are much better than
the Plane Quiet Platinum headphones, but the Bose QC3, Bose QC2
and the Sony MDR-NC500D headphones are all perceptibly better
than the Phiaton PS300 (and, of course, appreciably more
expensive too).
Sound Quality
We list this after noise
cancelling because we consider it to be a less important
consideration when choosing noise cancelling headphones.
Such headphones are never
used in a quiet listening environment with studio quality
equipment. They are, by definition, used in a noisy
environment, and usually with some type of portable music source
- both detract massively from the ability to enjoy a best
quality sound. Noise cancelling headphones should give
acceptably good quality sound, but beyond that, there's no point
in paying extra for theoretically better sound that you won't
notice with MP3 sourced music in a noisy environment.
With that as introduction,
the Phiaton headphones give only a moderate quality sound.
The bass is 'muddy' and unclear, no matter whether the bass
adjust control is set to the "+" or "-" setting.
A prominent mid-range gives
the sound a noticeable tonal coloration. Higher frequency
notes are very clear indeed, but perhaps a bit over-pronounced
and strident. Looking inside the headphones showed the
reason for the clarity of the high notes - there is a separate
mini-tweeter provided, something not many other headphones of
this type offer.
The sound quality is fine
for casual listening to music and for watching movies, but if
you're a serious audiophile wanting to do some high level
listening to first class music recordings, these are not the
headphones for you.
Comfort and Convenience
The Phiaton headphones
externally are very similar to the Bose QC3, and the earpads
look almost identical. However, the Phiaton earpads are
much firmer than the QC3 earpads - the QC3 sort of sinks onto
one's ears, whereas the Phiaton stands more above them.
It is hard however to say
which is more comfortable - both are acceptable, but generally I
prefer 'around the ear' designs (such as the Bose QC2 and QC15)
to the 'on the ear' design as featured with the Phiaton and QC3.
In terms of convenience, the
on/off switch is inconveniently located behind one of the
headphone mounts, but for most of us, there's little need to be
turning the headphones on and off other than when first putting
them on and when subsequently removing them at the end of a
journey, so this isn't very important.
The detachable headset cord
makes it easy to get up from your seat (if on a plane) while
leaving the headphones on, but without having a cord trailing
behind you.
The folding nature of the
headphones makes it possible to carry them in a smaller size
pouch than the QC3 headphones which don't fold at the earcups.
Being supplied with two
batteries and several different battery charging solutions is
definitely a convenience for when you're traveling away from
home, and the ability of the headphones to work with no battery
at all (to play music but not provide noise cancelling) is an
excellent 'emergency' capability if you find yourself with two
dead batteries. Unfortunately, the Bose QC3 only works
with the battery on - if your battery dies with the QC3, you
can't listen to music at all, with or without noise cancelling.
Phiaton PS300 NC compared to
Bose Quiet Comfort 3
The remarkable design
similarity between these two sets of headphones makes us suspect
they have both been designed and possibly even produced in the
same plant in China.
But while they are
superficially similar, there are some important differences in
performance. This table highlights the similarities and
differences between them :
Feature |
Phiaton
PS300 |
Bose QC3 |
List Price |
$299 |
$349 |
Street Price |
$199 |
$349 |
Street Price
with spare battery and worldwide charger |
$199 |
$449 |
1/4" adapter
included |
Yes |
No |
USB charger
included |
Yes |
No |
Standard
plugs on detachable cable |
No |
No |
'On head'
weight of headphones and battery only |
4.9 oz |
5.1 oz |
Weight of
headphones, battery, charger, cord |
6.2 oz |
7.4 oz |
Weight of
headphones, battery, charger, cord, case |
11.1 oz |
15.0 oz |
Carry case
size (max dimensions) |
5.5 x 6.0 x
2.4" |
6.5 x 8.0 x
2.0" |
Comfort on
ear |
good firmer
padding |
very good
soft padding |
Battery life
claimed |
18 hrs |
20 hrs |
Works with
no battery |
Yes |
No |
Warranty |
1 yr |
1 yr |
Background
hiss |
almost
completely imperceptible |
very low but
slightly noisier |
Noise
cancelling |
very good
low freq
good high freq |
excellent
low freq
good high |
Sound
quality |
fair |
very good |
|
Where to Buy
The headphones can be
purchased
direct from the manufacturer
at full list price ($299).
Although
Amazon
also sell
them, there's very little discount offered - currently there's
an alternate source offering them through Amazon for $276.
But if you go to
Headphone Solutions, you'll find them available for the much
better price of $199.
Summary and Recommendation
If you're someone who must
have the very best, you'll instead opt for one of the top three
headphones - the Bose QC2 or QC3, or the Sony MDR-NC500D, and
you'll happily pay the $300+ price associated with top of the
line units.
If you're someone who simply
wants a decent pair of headphones, better than you get on an
airplane, and with better noise cancelling than on airplane
headphones (which varies from none at all to very little), you
might choose the great value Plane Quiet Platinum headphones,
costing something less than $100.
And if you can't really
justify spending $300+ on headphones, while wanting something
better than a sub-$100 set of headphones with only limited noise
cancelling, the Phiaton product is probably a good choice as a
mid-range unit both in terms of price and performance.
Related Articles, etc
|
If so, please donate to keep the website free and fund the addition of more articles like this. Any help is most appreciated - simply click below to securely send a contribution through a credit card and Paypal.
|
Originally published
2 Oct 2009, last update
21 Jul 2020
You may freely reproduce or distribute this article for noncommercial purposes as long as you give credit to me as original writer.
|